Closer is such a different kind of thing... a brilliant remix, for once. But you gotta look at the source material here. MC Hammer? Fuck off is right. Not to mention that I think Gataka sorta sucks... poppy israeli full-on garbage vs ultra killer south african madness... no question what's bettah.
I think I am seeing a pattern here.
Remixing 80s and 90s euro, dance, and pop = very questionable.
Remixing 90s industrial and metal = some good results! (south of hell, rain, closer)
Remixing 90s rave, techno, and trance = hmm, really not sure.
I think Shift is 3 for 3 as far as remixes go... undoubtably the remix king. Nine Inch Nails, Age of Love, and Megadeath, all successfully remixed. Killah.