good "production" helps but should not be the focus... for example i can listen to the new planet b.e.n. and be boggled at how crisp and full those heavy kicks are, but the music doesnt move me. meanwhile i can get tunes from an impulse tracker mod stuck in my head because hey, music is music ya know!
creativity > production
(of course, creativity is enhanced greatly by good production!)
on the topic of the buddhas and groups with a dirty sound... well if thats the intention then whats so wrong? "oh no, here's a song that doesnt have gms basslines !!!"