abasio Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 Templar said: The topic should be titled: When will Ale finally score? Choose your year. 597899[/snapback] Score a decent album or score with a memeber of the opposite ? Quote
NEMO.BOFH Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 long ripps said: I don't think so ... there will always be someone listening to it. and as long as someone hears it, it's not dead (imo of caurse ) 597911[/snapback] No, if someone listens but its not being produced, then its dead.... Quote
NEMO.BOFH Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 Insejn said: When is a genre dead? When it's stopped being produced or what? 597875[/snapback] Yes Quote
Insejn Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 nemo said: Yes 598188[/snapback] So nothing is dead? Quote
NEMO.BOFH Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 Insejn said: So nothing is dead? 598189[/snapback] Many subgenres are dead... main genres no... except for Punk I guess. Quote
Insejn Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 nemo said: Many subgenres are dead... main genres no... except for Punk I guess. 598192[/snapback] So nobody makes Punk anymore? Wow... Quote
NEMO.BOFH Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 Insejn said: So nobody makes Punk anymore? Wow... 598196[/snapback] For me, no, I wouldnt call Greenday and the likes punk rock. For me it died with The Sexpistols... it can be discussed, but this is my opinion... Quote
Insejn Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 nemo said: For me, no, I wouldnt call Greenday and the likes punk rock. For me it died with The Sexpistols... it can be discussed, but this is my opinion... 598197[/snapback] I'm sure if you look deeper than Greenday you will for sure find some punk. I think... Quote
NEMO.BOFH Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 Insejn said: I'm sure if you look deeper than Greenday you will for sure find some punk. I think... 598199[/snapback] "some" punk, but then it would be a deviation of the genre, hence something LIKE punk, but not PUNK... Quote
abasio Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 Deep underground someone is producing exactly what you call punk, right now. But you'll never hear it. Isn't that sad? The best song you would ever hear is also never going to be heard by you! Damn world with it's 6 billion people Quote
NEMO.BOFH Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 abasio said: Deep underground someone is producing exactly what you call punk, right now. But you'll never hear it. Isn't that sad? The best song you would ever hear is also never going to be heard by you! Damn world with it's 6 billion people 598205[/snapback] yep, very true probably... and I am sad about that.... but hey, there is so much music out there, that I will not be able to hear anyways Quote
abasio Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 nemo said: yep, very true probably... and I am sad about that.... but hey, there is so much music out there, that I will not be able to hear anyways 598207[/snapback] It's what Always gets me I know the best music I've never heard is somewhere but I have absolutely no idea about it & probably never will. Still the search is fun if expensive Quote
NEMO.BOFH Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 abasio said: It's what Always gets me I know the best music I've never heard is somewhere but I have absolutely no idea about it & probably never will. Still the search is fun if expensive 598210[/snapback] Go on a music hunt around the world Quote
abasio Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 nemo said: Go on a music hunt around the world 598211[/snapback] Tried that but got stuck in Japan. Discover more here than I ever have before! Quote
Insejn Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 nemo said: "some" punk, but then it would be a deviation of the genre, hence something LIKE punk, but not PUNK... 598200[/snapback] Let me refrase that and just say what Abasio said There is PUNK there. It's just hard to find. Quote
NEMO.BOFH Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 Insejn said: Let me refrase that and just say what Abasio said There is PUNK there. It's just hard to find. 598229[/snapback] No there isnt, not for me... thats what I said before, according to MY standards, there is no punk made today. (PUNTO FINAL) For your standards maybe yes, thats why I said IMO Quote
Insejn Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 nemo said: No there isnt, not for me... thats what I said before, according to MY standards, there is no punk made today. (PUNTO FINAL) For your standards maybe yes, thats why I said IMO 598239[/snapback] How the hell do you know? Have you heard all punk on the planet? Didn't think so either. You have not found punk in what you have checked out so far. Or what? Quote
NEMO.BOFH Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 Insejn said: How the hell do you know? Have you heard all punk on the planet? Didn't think so either. You have not found punk in what you have checked out so far. Or what? 598241[/snapback] Whatever, for me punk is dead... and if it doesnt exist in MY world, it doesnt exist for ME Thats all I am saying. If it SOMEDAY (if it does exist, because you cant prove the contrary either) will reach my ears, I will post it RIGHT HERE in this thread Quote
Insejn Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 nemo said: Whatever, for me punk is dead... and if it doesnt exist in MY world, it doesnt exist for ME Thats all I am saying. If it SOMEDAY (if it does exist, because you cant prove the contrary either) will reach my ears, I will post it RIGHT HERE in this thread 598245[/snapback] If it SOMEDAY will reach your ears it isn't dead is it? haha Ok, I'll get off your back now Quote
NEMO.BOFH Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 Insejn said: If it SOMEDAY will reach your ears it isn't dead is it? haha Ok, I'll get off your back now 598246[/snapback] NEW POLL: Remove Insejn as an Admin Yes 99% 99 vote(s) No 1% 1 vote(s) Quote
Insejn Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 nemo said: NEW POLL: Remove Insejn as an Admin Yes 99% 99 vote(s) No 1% 1 vote(s) 598249[/snapback] I can manipulate those numbers Quote
abasio Posted September 2, 2006 Posted September 2, 2006 nemo said: NEW POLL: Remove Insejn as an Admin Yes 99% 99 vote(s) No 1% 1 vote(s) 598249[/snapback] Exactly 100 votes? What a coincidence. It made the maths very easy Quote
Deepdrone Posted September 3, 2006 Posted September 3, 2006 nemo said: No there isnt, not for me... thats what I said before, according to MY standards, there is no punk made today. (PUNTO FINAL) For your standards maybe yes, thats why I said IMO 598239[/snapback] If one always says IMO theres no discussion Quote
ironmonkey Posted September 5, 2006 Posted September 5, 2006 Ale said: 1999 is the year of death of goa trance with Atmos Headcleaner I'm waiting the death of todays psytrance. i hope no virus/worm modify my poll. 597086[/snapback] As long as people are listening to and enjoying the music it will never die. Goa didn't die. Psytrance didn't die. So many people on this forum alone listen to goa/psy daily and talk about it here with other people daily. That sure doesn't seem like a dead art form. Is classical music dead because Britney Spears or the latest EMO/Metal band is whining/screeching their latest laments? Nope. To say that Atmos destroyed Goa is ludicrous. All Atmos did was create a delicious and groovy new flavor of electronica. Atmos created something new he did not destroy something that existed. Edit: And as for punk rock being dead I'm not sure but I do know that Green Day, Good Charlotte, etc. that is being called Punk today isn't imo. However, the Dead Kennedys are playing at a small venue about 5 miles from me on Sept 17th. So, it seems like the heartbeat of punk is still there somewhere. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.