Jump to content

Complaints about Moderation.


NEMO.BOFH

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 1.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

more of a question than complaint, but i guess i bring it here-

any particular reason to why this

http://www.psynews.org/forums/index.php?showtopic=29708

 

thread is locked?

seems like most of the freestyle section is locked, and much of it for no clear reason, although osme of those threads, not surprised they're locked.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

All Freestyle section is closed. It's a "read only" area.

It has been locked because many people arrived to posting mostly there, and lots of it was meaningless conversation. Psynews is a forum, not a chat program.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

All Freestyle section is closed. It's a "read only" area.

It has been locked because many people arrived to posting mostly there, and lots of it was meaningless conversation. Psynews is a forum, not a chat program.

There's a whole 'Freestyle Thread' in the 'Off-topic' section instead now.

omg moniluff, whats up with the isratrancelation of psynews? What do you think is going on in Offtopic, like it has been forever? tsk

Unless I missed your point and you have no problems with the Offtopic section acting like a chill-out area aka. chat and goof and serious business :rolleyes:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There's a whole 'Freestyle Thread' in the 'Off-topic' section instead now.

omg moniluff, whats up with the isratrancelation of psynews? What do you think is going on in Offtopic, like it has been forever? tsk

Unless I missed your point and you have no problems with the Offtopic section acting like a chill-out area aka. chat and goof and serious business :rolleyes:

Freestyle was worse than Off Topic. In Off Topic people can still find something readable.

 

ok thanks

 

the topic i linked to was actually more psy related anyway so i may put up a post in genreal, if you hate it i guess you'll delete it, should be ok/

Please do.

The Freestyle section was all closed down, not just the topic you pointed out. Maybe that topic should have been moved from there before closing down the section.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Freestyle was worse than Off Topic. In Off Topic people can still find something readable.

people = mods?

 

 

ps. i think it's a shame chokuro's choco busin thread got closed down before she could post in it herself. strydr should get some warnings for meaninglessly spamming it :ph34r:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Freestyle was worse than Off Topic. In Off Topic people can still find something readable.

eh, among the lamest "reasons" ever if you ask me... NO ONE was FORCED into READING and POSTING in FREESTYLE! HELLLOOOOOOOO?! WAKE UP!

 

 

people = mods?

ps. i think it's a shame chokuro's choco busin thread got closed down before she could post in it herself. strydr should get some warnings for meaninglessly spamming it :ph34r:

ah, we missed chokuros real life busins :(?

 

 

true...

get out :blink:
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I never got the chance to walk inside the world of the Freestyle section. But in a way it seemed like a unessesary section to have since we had offtopic.

 

I guess it was actually a Off-Topic V. 2 - Extreme edition or something, haha

Link to comment
Share on other sites

eh, among the lamest "reasons" ever if you ask me... NO ONE was FORCED into READING and POSTING in FREESTYLE! HELLLOOOOOOOO?! WAKE UP!

Try to post this at other forums and see the result. I think you got it VERY good here.

Nobody forces no one to post nosense, but they still do. Where's the sense in that?

Why don't you make your own forum, with your own rules, or non-rules if you want?

The purpose of a forum is to have discussion inside, so that those discussions can attract people in. It should be obvious.

 

Why was the Freestyle section made in the fist place?

Because people complained that Off Topic had too many topics full of spam, nonsense, small dialogue, and that topics that were actually about somehting serious (cultural, spiritual), were getting lost the spam. So we decided to create a sub-section for such topics, the "Cultural / Spiritual zone".

Then the others got angry and felt they were loosing attention (kidding :P) because of the separation, and they asked a Freestyle zone, where they could post nonsense and bullshit and whatever came to their minds. So the "Freestyle Section" got created.

But the Freestyle Section started to become bigger and bigger each day (few people were still posting in Cultural and Off Topic). If you check it, you will see that people posted there whatever crossed their minds. Freestyle became the support for chat, which is not the purpose of a forum. Then Mars decided to close down Freestyle, and reduce the spam. Some members still want Freestyle back, but it won't happen.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Try to post this at other forums and see the result. I think you got it VERY good here.

Nobody forces no one to post nosense, but they still do. Where's the sense in that?

Why don't you make your own forum, with your own rules, or non-rules if you want?

The purpose of a forum is to have discussion inside, so that those discussions can attract people in. It should be obvious.

hehe, it did attract people, thats the whole point ;) oh and i dont care atm about "other forums" - its psynews and were talking about it and not about some knitting forum. and why would i have to make my own forum? is that required if one wants free discussions without censorship nor other stupid limitations [which were almost non existent in freestyle and that was good]? cool!
Link to comment
Share on other sites

hehe, it did attract people, thats the whole point ;) oh and i dont care atm about "other forums" - its psynews and were talking about it and not about some knitting forum. and why would i have to make my own forum? is that required if one wants free discussions without censorship nor other stupid limitations [which were almost non existent in freestyle and that was good]? cool!

I did attract people... to do what? Spam? There are chat programs for that.

 

And i suggested that you make your own forum (just to see how it is), cause you're always so rebel and you will never agree for anything with the way Psynews is administrated. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

when there is something i dont like more than usual, i dare to disagree. you can stay silent for anything that happens around.

what i dont like is, moderators are hardly posting themselves and i rarely see them browsing this forum. perhaps we need new moderators ;)?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

when there is something i dont like more than usual, i dare to disagree. you can stay silent for anything that happens around.

what i dont like is, moderators are hardly posting themselves and i rarely see them browsing this forum. perhaps we need new moderators ;)?

Moderators don't have the function of entertainers, so don't worry if we don't post much. :P

I don't know if psynews needs new mods now. There are 5 mods and 2 admins, totally 7. And the members are more or less behaving in this period. Which we thank them for.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

when there is something i dont like more than usual, i dare to disagree. you can stay silent for anything that happens around.

what i dont like is, moderators are hardly posting themselves and i rarely see them browsing this forum. perhaps we need new moderators ;)?

Maybe you should think WHY some mods are not present that much anymore. Sure, some like DP and moni actually got a life but to be honest I'm not exactly feeling like posting much when there is mainly chatting going on in the off topic instead of discussions. If I wanna chat I go to chatroom or open my messenger... I'm not saying you (people in general) have to change their ways but if you demand that everybody and their pets participate too I have to disagree.

 

Btw. it would really do you good to listen to moni and open up your own forum just to see what happens. :P:D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

moderation schmoderation....

 

I just wonder why so many NON mods are not coming here too often anymore =) I mean, not even one of my good friends likes to come here anymore....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

moderation schmoderation....

 

I just wonder why so many NON mods are not coming here too often anymore =) I mean, not even one of my good friends likes to come here anymore....

Same reason as above stated maybe? :huh:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

eh, among the lamest "reasons" ever if you ask me... NO ONE was FORCED into READING and POSTING in FREESTYLE! HELLLOOOOOOOO?! WAKE UP!

My lord, that irritated me so much you wont beleive it.

 

Freestyle is nothing but absolute shit. A place for people who are "trying" to be funny, but are failing miserably.

 

 

EDIT: If the age-old rule of "only speaking when you have something intelligent or funny to say" applied to you reger, I think we would be hearing a hell of a lot less from you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think the rational angle is somewhere between reger's and moni's. Both are right. Off-topic isn't entirely about being "readable" and communicative, it's also about expressing oneself, and often that takes the form of what most would call spam. Either way, to hinder or censor one's expression is essentially a violent act, and to spam someone's forum, when there are rules against such a thing, is essentially violent too. The key is finding some compromise. As in, if you have to spam, do it with some tact, and if you have to moderate, do it, too, with some feeling for what's really harming people. My opinion.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think the rational angle is somewhere between reger's and moni's. Both are right. Off-topic isn't entirely about being "readable" and communicative, it's also about expressing oneself, and often that takes the form of what most would call spam. Either way, to hinder or censor one's expression is essentially a violent act, and to spam someone's forum, when there are rules against such a thing, is essentially violent too. The key is finding some compromise. As in, if you have to spam, do it with some tact, and if you have to moderate, do it, too, with some feeling for what's really harming people. My opinion.

Couldnt agree more. Except I feel its more a 70% - 30% split in regers favour with regards to not compromising.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

moderation schmoderation....

 

I just wonder why so many NON mods are not coming here too often anymore =) I mean, not even one of my good friends likes to come here anymore....

Who's that you're talking about?
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...