Please vote - Which Version is Better?

[needle ninja]

This isn't psytrance, don't hate me for that, but I honestly want to know which one of these you prefer.

I made the first last year and then I decided to redo it because it wasn't enough like the kind of music I was listening to at the time so I rearranged it. I changed quite a lot really. I deleted the first version on everything but my dvd backup disk and haven't listened to it since.

Now, months later I listened to it again and I'm having second thoughts.

 

Original version:

newer version

[Rotwang]

I think I prefer the newer version.

[Padmapani]

the second version sounds better production-wise. but i like the slower more subtle melodic elements in the first one better. in the second one the main melody imho gets annoying after a while.

[needle ninja]

Thank you both.

This thread can probably be locked now.